Player Development

Basketball Strengths and Weaknesses: How to Evaluate Your Own Game Honestly

A self-evaluation for players: rate 12 skills with real evidence, find the strength that earns you minutes and the weakness that costs them, and build a plan around both.

HE
HoopBrief EditorialCoaching Intelligence Team
9 min read
A player setting their feet for a jump shot in an empty practice gym
Honest self-evaluation starts with evidence, not feelings. AI-assisted editorial image by HoopBrief.

Most players answer "what are your strengths and weaknesses?" with words like "shooting" and "defense." That answer helps nobody. A coach wants to know what you do well enough to be trusted with it in a game, and what an opponent would do to take you out of the game. This guide turns the question into something you can measure.

If you play on a team, the same idea works for coaches: our guide to self-scouting blind spots covers it from the team side.

Step 1: Rate 12 skills with evidence

Score each skill from 1 to 5. The rule is simple: you can only give yourself a 4 or 5 if you can point to evidence. Evidence is a number from a workout, something that happens over and over in games, or something a coach has told you.

Skill1 to 5Evidence
Catch-and-shoot threeMakes out of 50 in a workout
Shooting off the dribblePull-ups made out of 25 each side
Finishing at the rim, both handsLayups out of 20 with your weak hand
Free throwsMakes out of 50
Ball handling under pressureTurnovers in your last three games
Passing and court visionAssists and turnovers
On-ball defenseWho scored on you, and how
Help defense and rotationsCoach feedback, film
ReboundingRebounds per game for your position
ConditioningHow you feel in the fourth quarter
CommunicationDo teammates hear you on defense?
Basketball IQScore on our basketball IQ test

Be strict. If you shoot 40 percent on catch-and-shoot threes in an empty gym, your game percentage will usually be lower with a defender closing out. Write down what you can prove.

Step 2: Ask how a scouting report would describe you

Now imagine the other team's coach is writing a scouting report about you. What would it say? Usually a report has three lines:

1. What he does best. "Strong left-hand driver, gets to the rim." 2. How we stop it. "Force him right, help early on drives." 3. What he cannot do. "Does not shoot off the dribble going right."

Write these three lines about yourself. Line 3 is your biggest weakness, because it is the one the other team will plan around. If you cannot write line 3, ask a coach or a teammate. They know.

Our guide to scouting your own game goes deeper on thinking like the person scouting you.

Step 3: Find the strength that earns minutes

A strength only matters if it helps your team win. A great crossover that never leads to a good shot is not a strength a coach can use. The strengths that earn minutes are usually simple:

RoleStrengths coaches trust
GuardTakes care of the ball, defends the ball, makes the right pass
WingMakes open threes, guards the other team's best wing, runs the floor
BigSets good screens, rebounds, protects the rim, finishes around the basket
Any positionPlays hard, talks, knows where to be

Look at your ratings. Which skill would make a coach say "I need him on the floor"? That is the strength you protect. Practice it every week so it does not slip while you work on everything else.

Step 4: Pick one weakness, not five

Every player has five weaknesses. Trying to fix all of them at once means fixing none. Pick the one that most affects whether you play. Usually it is one of these:

  • The weakness a defense can attack every possession. If you cannot go right, every defender will force you right.
  • The weakness that takes you off the floor. If you cannot guard anyone, the coach cannot play you even when you score.
  • The weakness that blocks the next level. If you want to play guard in college but cannot handle pressure, that matters more than anything else.

Write one sentence: "My biggest weakness is ___, and it costs me ___." For example: "My biggest weakness is finishing with my left hand, and it costs me layups because defenders force me left at the rim."

Step 5: Build a four-week plan

WeekWeakness work (most of your time)Strength work
1Learn the skill slowly with perfect formKeep reps at game speed
2Add speed, still no defenderSame
3Add a defender or a chaserUse it in games
4Use it in pick-up or team scrimmages and count resultsSame

Count your results at the start and end. If you started at 9 out of 20 left-hand layups and finished at 15, the plan worked. If not, change the drill, not the goal.

Examples by position

Seeing real examples makes it easier to write your own. Here is what a strong self-evaluation looks like at each position.

Point guard. Strength: "Takes care of the ball. Two turnovers or fewer in most games, and I can bring it up against pressure." Weakness: "Shooting off the dribble going right. Defenders go under screens on me because they do not respect the pull-up." Plan: pull-ups off a screen going right, 50 a day, four days a week.

Wing. Strength: "Catch-and-shoot threes, about 38 percent in workouts with a closeout." Weakness: "Attacking a closeout. When the defender runs at me, I take a bad shot instead of driving." Plan: closeout drill with a partner, shot fake and one-dribble pull-up or drive.

Big. Strength: "Rebounding and screening. I lead the team in rebounds and our guards get open off my screens." Weakness: "Finishing with my left hand around the basket." Plan: Mikan drill and left-hand hooks daily, then contact finishing.

Notice that every example uses a number or a specific game situation. "I'm a good shooter" is a guess. "38 percent on catch-and-shoot threes with a closeout" is evidence.

How to answer "what are your strengths and weaknesses?" at a tryout

Coaches at tryouts and camps often ask this question. A good answer is short, specific and shows you know your game. Here is a simple template:

"My strength is ___. In our last season I ___. My weakness is ___, and I am working on it by ___."

Example: "My strength is defending the ball. I usually guard the other team's best guard. My weakness is shooting off the dribble. I am working on pull-ups going right four days a week, and I went from 8 to 13 out of 25 this month."

That answer tells a coach three things: you know your role, you know your gap and you are working on it with numbers. The tryout evaluation rubric shows what coaches grade during tryouts.

Common mistakes in self-evaluation

  • Rating yourself on your best day. Use your average day.
  • Calling effort a skill. "I play hard" is important, but it is not a skill on a scouting report.
  • Ignoring defense. Most players rate their offense in detail and defense in one line.
  • Never asking anyone else. A coach's view is the closest you will get to the other team's scouting report.

Get a plan built for your game

HoopBrief can turn your self-evaluation into a training plan. Tell it your position, level, height and the weakness you wrote down, and it returns drills, rep counts and a weekly schedule. You can ask now with any plan, from $9.99 a month.

With Starter ($9.99 a month), you get unlimited answers and follow-ups, so you can come back each week, report your numbers and get the next week's plan. Parents can buy it for a player under 18. The Matchup Scout also shows how NBA players at your position attack the same weaknesses you are working on.

See it on a real matchup

Turn this into a scouting report

Ask HoopBrief how this applies to a real player, matchup, or team and get a scouting-style breakdown in seconds. Starter is $9.99/mo.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know my basketball strengths and weaknesses?

Rate 12 skills from 1 to 5 using evidence: workout makes out of attempts, what happens in games and what coaches have told you. Then write the three lines a scouting report would say about you. The skill an opponent would attack first is your biggest weakness.

What are good basketball strengths to say in a tryout?

Specific strengths coaches can use: defending the ball, making open threes, taking care of the ball, rebounding or setting good screens. Back it up with an example or a number from your last season.

How do you answer what is your biggest weakness in basketball?

Name one specific skill, say how it affects your game, and say what you are doing about it with a number. For example: shooting off the dribble going right, working on it four days a week, up from 8 to 13 out of 25 this month.

Should I work on strengths or weaknesses in basketball?

Both, but not equally. Spend most practice time on the one weakness that most affects your minutes and keep your best strength sharp with regular reps, so it does not slip while you improve.

Sources

  1. FIBA WABC Level 2 Coaches Manual, player evaluation and individual development

About the Author

HE

HoopBrief Editorial

Coaching Intelligence Team

HoopBrief's coaching-intelligence team explains basketball decisions using the same 12-lens framework available in subscriber reports.

Newsletter

Get the next playoff brief in your inbox.

Coaching-lens coverage of every NBA playoff series, plus the micro-behavior tags from the subscriber reports. Free, weekly.

We'll never share your email. Unsubscribe in one click.