Coaching

How to Scout the Opponent's Best Player: A One-Page Report Your Team Can Use

A coach's method for scouting the other team's best player: what to watch, the six questions that matter, a one-page player report and how to turn it into a defensive plan.

HE
HoopBrief EditorialCoaching Intelligence Team
9 min read
A scout's notebook, pencil, stopwatch, and basketball beside a live practice
A player scouting report is six answers and one plan, not a page of adjectives. AI-assisted editorial image by HoopBrief.

Most games against a good team come down to their best player. If your team takes away what that player does best, the rest of their team has to beat you. Most teams do not have five players who can. That is why the best-player report is the most valuable page in any scouting report.

This guide works whether you have film, one live viewing or only what other coaches tell you.

What to watch first

Before writing anything, watch the player for at least eight possessions where he has the ball. Do not watch the ball when he does not have it. Watch him. Where does he go? How does he get open? Who sets screens for him?

If you have one game of film, watch it twice: once for the team, once only for him. If you are scouting live, sit at the end of the floor where you can see his feet and which way he turns. If you have no film at all, our guide to scouting an opponent without film explains what to ask other coaches.

The six questions

1. Which hand and which direction?

Almost every player has a favorite hand and direction. Watch his drives and count: how many go right, how many go left? Watch his finishes: does he use his weak hand, or does he switch hands to avoid it? This one answer tells your on-ball defender where to stand before he catches.

2. Where does he like to shoot?

Make a quick shot chart from the film or the game. Is he a catch-and-shoot player or an off-the-dribble shooter? Does he pull up going one direction? Does he take long twos or get all the way to the rim? Mark the three spots he shoots from most often.

3. How does he score when the play breaks down?

Every good player has a go-to move when nothing else works: a step-back, a spin, a drive to his strong hand. This is usually what he does late in the shot clock. Write it down in plain words: "late clock, goes left, step-back jumper."

4. What does he do against pressure?

Does he handle a trap or panic? Does he pass out of double teams, or try to score through them? This tells you whether sending help will work or whether it will open teammates.

5. How does he defend?

The best player on offense is often saving energy on defense. Does he help, or stay home? Does he close out hard? If he is a weak defender, your offense should attack whoever he guards. Coaches often forget this part of the report.

6. What does he do late in games?

In close games, does he want the ball? Does the team run the same play for him every time? Late-game tendencies are often the most predictable thing in a scouting report, because teams go back to what they trust.

The one-page player report

SectionWhat to writeExample
Name and rolePosition, height, role#3, 6-foot-1 guard, primary scorer
Strong hand and directionCount from filmDrives left about 3 out of 4 times
Favorite shotsThree spotsPull-up from left elbow, left-wing three, layups
Go-to moveLate clockStep-back going left
Against pressurePass or forceForces, turns it over against traps
On defenseStrength or weaknessStays home, does not help
Late gameTheir go-to playSide ball screen, drives left
Our planOne sentenceForce him right, help on left-hand drives, trap ball screens late

Only write what you saw or what you can confirm. If you are guessing, mark it with a question mark and watch for it in the first four minutes. A report that sounds certain but is wrong is worse than a short report that is honest.

Turn the report into a defensive plan

A report is only useful when it becomes a plan. Answer three things:

Who guards him? Usually your best on-ball defender. But think about foul trouble and energy. If your best defender is also your best scorer, a second defender for some minutes may be the better choice.

How do you guard his favorite action? If he scores off ball screens going left, decide your coverage: ice the screen, go over and show, or trap. Every player on the floor needs to know it, not only the defender on him.

When does help come? Decide where your help defenders stand and when they leave. Against a driver, help from the nail. Against a post scorer, decide if you double on the catch or on the dribble. Tell your players exactly which teammate they can leave to help.

A worked example

Here is how six answers turn into a plan. Say your scout of their best guard, #3, found the following: drives left most of the time, likes pull-ups from the left elbow, step-back going left late in the clock, forces shots against traps, stays home on defense and gets a side ball screen in close games.

The plan writes itself from those answers. Your best on-ball defender guards him and shades his left hand. On ball screens, you ice the side screens to keep him from going left toward the middle. Your help defender at the nail is ready on every left drive. Late in games, you trap the side ball screen, because he forces shots against pressure. On offense, you attack whoever he guards, because he does not help.

Every part of that plan comes from something you saw. That is what makes it believable to players and useful in a game.

Adjusting during the game

Even a good scout can be wrong, or the player can have an unusual night. Check the plan in the first four minutes. If he is going right more than you expected, tell your defender at the first dead ball. If your help is coming too late, move the help defender up a step.

At halftime, count his shots by type: how many came from his favorite spots, and how many from where you wanted him to shoot. If he is getting his favorite shots, change the coverage, not the defender, first. If he is scoring on shots you were willing to give up, it may just be a good night, and the plan can stay.

Teach it to your players

Players remember three things. Give them three:

1. His strong hand. "Force him right." 2. His favorite shot. "No left-elbow pull-ups." 3. The help rule. "Help on every left drive. Leave the corner only if it is their worst shooter."

Write them on the whiteboard, walk them through in practice and say the same words during timeouts. The defender guarding him should practice against a teammate playing his role, including his go-to move. Our guide on presenting a scouting report to players covers this in detail.

Common mistakes

  • Writing adjectives instead of actions. "Athletic, good scorer" helps nobody. "Drives left, pulls up from the left elbow" does.
  • Scouting only his offense. His defense tells your offense where to attack.
  • Making the plan too complicated. One coverage your team executes is better than three it half-understands.
  • Forgetting the rest of the team. If you send help, decide who you are leaving open, and make sure it is their weakest shooter.

Build the player plan in minutes

HoopBrief's free Game Plan scout has a section for exactly this: add up to three opponent players, tap their position and what they do (shooter, driver, post scorer, strong left hand), and add notes. HoopBrief builds the plan around them with matchups, coverages and the help rule, using your player names and only the numbers you give it. It works for any team at any level, including teams with no film online.

On Starter ($9.99 a month), you can scout every opponent on your schedule. Pro ($99 a month) adds timed practice plans and player install sheets, so the defender guarding their best player gets his own page before the game. For the whole team picture, start with the game plan example.

Your next opponent

Build the game plan for your next opponent

Tap what you know about the team you play next and HoopBrief builds the plan: matchups, the coverage to play, what to run against them. It comes with every plan: Starter is $9.99/mo, or $79 for a whole season.

Keep going · Chapter 3 of 10

Scouting their best players

Six questions to answer about any star, a one-page player sheet, and who guards him and when help comes.

  • One chapter of The Game Plan Playbook, 87 pages
  • 8 printable templates: scouting sheets, the one-page plan, a halftime card
  • Two-day and four-day prep practices, with drills tied to each key
See the playbook · $29One payment · instant PDF download

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you scout an opposing team's best player?

Watch at least eight possessions with him on the ball and answer six questions: his strong hand and direction, favorite shots, go-to move late in the clock, how he handles pressure, how he defends and what he does late in games. Then decide who guards him, how you guard his favorite action and when help comes.

What should a player scouting report include?

Role, strong hand and direction, favorite shot spots, go-to move, behavior against pressure, defense, late-game tendencies and a one-sentence plan to stop him. Keep it to one page and mark anything you have not confirmed.

Should you double team the other team's best player?

Only if your scout shows he struggles against pressure and you have decided which teammate to leave open, ideally their weakest shooter. If he passes well out of double teams, a strong single defender with help on his favorite action is usually better.

How do you scout a player without film?

Watch him live from the end of the floor, ask coaches who have played against him, and check box scores for how he scores. Mark anything uncertain and confirm it in the first few minutes of the game.

Sources

  1. FIBA WABC Level 2 Coaches Manual, scouting and game preparation

About the Author

HE

HoopBrief Editorial

Coaching Intelligence Team

HoopBrief's coaching-intelligence team explains basketball decisions using the same 12-lens framework available in subscriber reports.

Newsletter

Get the next playoff brief in your inbox.

Coaching-lens coverage of every NBA playoff series, plus the micro-behavior tags from the subscriber reports. Free, weekly.

We'll never share your email. Unsubscribe in one click.